DALLAS TWP. — A zoning board hearing regarding a permit application for an addiction treatment center at the former site of Commonwealth Health’s Back Mountain Medical Center will continue at 6 p.m. Tuesday, June 30 at the municipal building.
Although the board was expected to make a decision Monday, June 15 at the second continuance to the hearing which began May 11, it once again concluded with no vote after approximately 10 hours of testimony, cross examination and discussion spread over the three dates.
The project developer, David Rowland Interests Inc., filed the application in February and it was denied by Township Zoning and Code Enforcement Officer Carl Alber.
Alber said prior to the first continuance hearing he denied the application based on the Dallas Township Zoning Ordinance’s restrictions for A-1 (agricultural) districts. He explained this type of facility is not permitted by the code.
The company, however, claims it was never given proper written notice of the application denial. Rather, communication with the zoning officer was made via telephone, at which time the May 11 appeal hearing was scheduled.
The developer’s appeal is twofold. First, it is challenging Alber’s decision to refuse certification of zoning compliance or certification of nonconformity. Second, should the board’s determination be in agreement with Alber’s, the company seeks a special exception to change one nonconforming use to another.
The township brought up an issue regarding the combination of these two items at the June 15 continuance, stating it was not explained in that manor in the legal advertisement that provided public notice of the meeting. The developer claims this falls on the shoulders of the township, and the township claims it was by fault of the developer for not clearly explaining the company’s intentions.
At the close of Monday’s meeting, it was announced that all parties have one week to submit new proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law before the final hearing June 30.
David Rowland Interests Inc., owned by veteran developer David Rowland, is a real estate development, management and investment business which maintains properties throughout Pennsylvania, West Virginia and Florida. Rowland, who was in attendance at the hearing, hopes to convert the former medical center at 100 Upper Demunds Road into a 70-bed inpatient drug and alcohol rehabilitation center.
At least 30 residents attended the first two portions of the meeting and a slightly smaller amount at the third. Some were there to observe and ask questions, while others were in opposition to the location of the project.
Carmen Ambrosino, of Carmen Ambrosino LLC, provided expert testimony during the hearing on behalf of David Rowland Interests Inc. The retired CEO of Wyoming Valley Alcohol and Drug Services Inc. spoke of a “great need” in the region for more facilities like the one proposed, and gave several examples from his 41-year career.
“We looked for weapons of mass destruction in Iraq,” he said during the May 28 continuance. “We were looking in the wrong place. They’re in the United States. They’re drugs. They first will take the life of the individual, and the family and then the community, state, the nation and the world. As it relates to rehabilitation, we try to give back the life to the individual and the family.”
Community members in the audience expressed agreement with Ambrosino regarding these sentiments, but pointed out the issue is not about helping addicts recover, but about zoning.
“One of the things that did concern me about this, is we’ve heard a lot about treatment,” said township resident Alan Pugh in testimony May 28. “And I can certainly tell you, from losing a relative to this (the problem of addiction), I agree with all that. But this is about zoning. To me, all this other stuff is great, but, the property isn’t zoned right, and I think it’s important to see that.”
Other residents made similar comments, saying they are opposed to the center’s proposed location — which is near a school and in an agricultural zone — not the project itself.
Rowland also testified during the hearing, explaining the project, which began about 15 months ago, and his role as a developer.
He said although the project involves altering the internal floor plan of the building, its overall footprint will remain the same, and no expansions are needed or planned. He expects exterior renovations and upgrades alone will cost around $1 million.
Plans for a state-of-the-art security system were also briefly outlined, along with plans to make the facility quickly and conveniently accessible to emergency personnel.
At the May 28 continuance hearing, concerns were raised regarding PennDOT’s major roadwork project in that vicinity and whether large fire trucks would have quick access to the property. Rowland came back to the June 15 meeting with documentation from the department showing that would not be a problem.
